The classic RPG dilemma: big slow weapon or fast precise weapon? In Elden Ring, both archetypes are viable from start to finish. This comparison covers damage, playstyle, weapon variety, and PvP viability.
Strength Builds
Stagger, trading, and maximum per-hit damage
Strengths
- Highest per-hit damage in the game
- Stagger bosses for critical hits
- Can wear heaviest armor without sacrifice
- Simple execution (jump attack everything)
- Lion's Claw and Royal Knight's Resolve are incredible
Weaknesses
- Slow attacks punish mistiming
- Fewer weapon choices
- Heavy equip load management
- Worse against fast, small enemies
- PvP requires more patience
VS
Dexterity Builds
Speed, bleed, and sustained DPS
Strengths
- Fast attacks exploit small openings
- Bleed adds percentage damage
- More weapon variety (katanas, twinblades, claws)
- Better casting speed bonus
- Stronger in PvP (faster weapons win trades)
Weaknesses
- Lower per-hit damage
- Less stagger potential
- Lighter armor means less poise
- Bleed-immune enemies are a problem
- More stat-hungry (often need Arcane too)
Verdict
Strength is simpler and more forgiving; Dexterity is faster and more versatile. For a first playthrough, Strength is easier to pick up. For PvP, Dexterity has more options. Both clear all content comfortably.